The Painted Girls by Cathy Marie Buchanan

January 14th, 2013

The Painted Girls by Cathy Buchanan is a wonderfully imagined piece of historical fiction by an extremely talented author. I was first captivated by Cathy’s writing when I read her first novel The Day the Falls Stood Still (my review) and loved it and she’s done it again. I can’t imagine the research and time that went into weaving the historical details with the beautifully told story of the sisters in The Painted Girls but it was well worth it because this is an amazing novel that brings to life 19th century Paris and those of the dancers and artists who lived in it.

Antoinette, Marie, and Charlotte don’t live the life of the privileged. In fact it’s a struggle just to survive for them. Their father passed away and their mother spends more time with her bottle of absinthe than with them. Antoinette has been in the ballet and both Marie and Charlotte apply also as it is the one way for them to get ahead in their world and also make a living. The story shifts between Antoinette and Marie and normally I would like one more than the other but the story shifted so seamlessly between the two that I was completely immersed in both of their worlds. These two sisters love each other fiercely and yet there is a rivalry there particularly in the ballet when Marie begins to be singled out by the painter Edgar Degas. She begins to model for him and make extra money but soon she is pressed into making decisions that she’s much too young to be making. As for Antoinette she falls for a boy and ends up taking a direction in her life that doesn’t lead her anywhere but downhill. Both girls will face hardships and heart wrenching decisions and both will suffer in different ways. Will their passion for what they believe and their strong sisterly bond be enough to lead them to the life they desire.

The characters in this book are so vividly brought to life; even the smallest one. The world of art and the ballet is so vividly described that I felt sure I was standing over the shoulder of the painter or sitting in the front seats of the ballet. From the beginning pages Antoinette and Marie, based on real sisters, captured my heart and I felt every sorrow and every triumph that they did. The book is also based on real murders that occurred and those pieces are intertwined throughout the book. You’d think they didn’t belong but they relate back to the story in quite a few ways. I was also really interested in the pieces on the artists as I have an interest in that time period although I haven’t looked into it as much as I should. After reading this book I did look up Edgar Degas’ work called ‘Little Dancer Aged Fourteen’ because it really piqued my curiosity and of course now I want to learn even more. I think it’s great when a book incites that kind of a reaction from its readers to learn more.

The Painted Girls by Cathy Marie Buchanan is a beautifully written book. Every single word and phrase takes you away to another place and time and opens up the world of artists and dancers in such a way that will evoke emotions within you and keep you enthralled within its pages and the lives it portrays. An excellent novel by a brilliant writer – well worth reading and highly recommended for the historical fiction fan and others!  Pick up your own copy at Amazon or Amazon Canada.

Source: Review copy provided by the Publisher. No compensation was received and all opinions are my own.

17 Comments to “The Painted Girls by Cathy Marie Buchanan”

  1. I love books that bring the characters to life. The fact that it is historical fiction is an added bonus. Lovely review.

  2. So glad to read that you enjoyed this one (yours is the first review I’ve read about it). Sounds like one I’d like.

  3. Mary says:

    Wow, Dar, this sounds really good! Great review.

  4. LOVE the cover and the review!

  5. Wow, your enthusiasm for this book is contagious! You’ve made it sound wonderful!

  6. Marie says:

    Great review, Dar! I loved the book, too. I’ll be posting mine tomorrow.

  7. Sandy says:

    I’ve heard such wonderful things about this book, AND it was on the Must List in EW this week. Plus I’ve just recently read The Art Forger which is also about Degas! It is fate that I must read this book.

  8. Nise' says:

    This book getting great reviews. It is going on my list to read for sure!

  9. Serena says:

    I’m so glad that you loved this book as much as I did. It was so well done.

  10. zibilee says:

    This is a book that I have been eager to read, and I am so glad that you read it and loved it! It tells such an interesting tale, and one that probably would intrigue the heck out of me. I can’t wait to get to it. Excellent review indeed. I loved it!

  11. I’ve heard nothing but good things about this book. I have The Day the Falls Stood Still but haven’t read it. Sounds like I need to read both!

  12. Want, want want want wantwantwant! 😉 “Every single word and phrase takes you away to another place and time…” YES — I love it when that happens!

  13. Staci@LifeintheThumb says:

    I have to read this one! Loved your beautifully written review….will be reading this one for sure!

  14. Thank you, Darlene. So glad I did not disappoint. Thank you for reading, reviewing and helping spread the word. You can check out all the artworks that are mentioned in the book at

  15. Lisa says:

    My book club is reading this one for February. Usually we try to wait until a book comes out in paperbook but this time I wouldn’t let them; I didn’t want to wait that long. Sounds like I’m going to be glad that I pushed for it now!

  16. […] January 14th: Review by Peeking Between the Pages […]

Leave a Reply




    Add to Google
    RSS via email

    Enter your email address:

    Grab My Button

    Follow My Blog With…
    Follow on Bloglovin
    Recently Shared